Right To Rent Breaches Human Rights Law
The High Court has ruled the government's Right to Rent scheme breaches human rights law.
Introduced by Theresa May, when she was Home Secretary, under the Right to Rent scheme, landlords are responsible for checking the immigration status of their tenants with the prospect of prosecution if they know or have "reasonable cause to believe" that the property they are letting is occupied by someone who does not have the right to rent in the UK.
The Residential Landlords Association joined with Liberty (an organisation which campaigns to make sure everyone in the UK is treated fairly) to intervene in a case brought by the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants (JCWI) to have the policy declared as incompatible with human rights on the grounds that it was leading to discrimination against non-UK nationals who might be in the country legitimately and British ethnic minorities.
Recent research by the RLA found that, the fear of getting things wrong led to 44 per cent of private landlords being less likely to rent to those without a British passport. It also found 53 per cent of landlords were less likely to rent to those with limited time to remain in the UK, whilst 20 per cent said that they were less likely to consider letting property to EU or EEA nationals.
Significantly, during the course of the case, government research emerged, which confirmed a significant proportion of landlords were unwilling to rent to people without British passports.
Delivering his verdict in the High Court, Mr Justice Martin Spencer ruled the scheme breached the European Convention on Human Rights on the basis that it led to discrimination against non-UK nationals with the right to rent and British ethnic minorities.
Mr Justice Spencer, referring extensively to argument and evidence provided by the RLA, concluded that discrimination by landlords was taking place "because of the Scheme."
He went on to conclude that "the government's own evaluation failed to consider discrimination on grounds of nationality at all, only on grounds of ethnicity."
The Judge continued by finding that the Right to Rent "does not merely provide the occasion or opportunity for private landlords to discriminate but causes them to do so where otherwise they would not", describing such discrimination by landlords a being "logical and wholly predicable"when faced with potential sanctions and penalties for getting things wrong.
He concluded: "The safeguards used by the government to avoid discrimination, namely online guidance, telephone advice and codes of conduct and practice, have proved ineffective. In my judgment, in those circumstances, the government cannot wash its hands of responsibility for the discrimination which is taking place by asserting that such discrimination is carried out by landlords acting contrary to the intention of the Scheme."
The RLA and the JCWI have written to the Home Secretary seeking an urgent meeting. Both organisations believe the government should scrap the scheme and go back to the drawing board.
David Smith, Policy Director for the Residential Landlords Association, said: "This ruling is a damning critique of a flagship Government policy. We have warned all along that turning landlords into untrained and unwilling border police would lead to the exact form of discrimination the court has found. We call on the government to accept the decision, scrap the Right to Rent, and consider what else can be done to sensibly manage migration, without having to rely on untrained landlords to do the job of the Home Office."
Chai Patel, Legal Policy Director for the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants added: "There is no place for racism in the UK housing market. Now that the High Court has confirmed that Theresa May's policy actively causes discrimination, Parliament must act immediately to scrap it".
Having trouble keeping track of new legislation? - Estates IT, supplies award winning PCHomes software to the Estate/Letting Agents industry, which manages all your documentation effortlessly. There is a specific module for tracking and maintaining licences, compliance and document information.
Book a demo for PCHomes Plus
Written by Deb Roberts
Source Estates IT Ltd
